Water law is old, local and surprisingly consequential. A farm with great soil and no legal right to water may be worth far less than the buyer thinks, and a farm whose water right is senior can be worth far more. Farmers who invest in irrigation, ponds or land should understand the basics. This article is a general primer, not legal advice. Water law differs sharply from state to state, and an attorney who practices water law in your state should review any significant transaction.
Two big doctrines
Riparian rights. Common in the humid East, riparian law ties water use to ownership of land next to a stream or lake. Landowners along the water have the right to make reasonable use of it, subject to the rights of other riparian owners. Many eastern states have layered permit systems on top for larger withdrawals.
Prior appropriation. Common in the arid West, it follows the principle often summarized as first in time, first in right. The first person to put water to beneficial use gets the senior right, and in a shortage, senior rights are filled before junior ones. Rights are usually defined by priority date, amount, point of diversion, place and purpose of use, and are administered by the state. Water use must continue, and unused rights can be lost under forfeiture or abandonment rules, often described as use it or lose it.
Some states use hybrids. California, Texas and others combine elements, for example recognizing riparian and appropriative rights in different contexts.
Surface water and groundwater
Rules for groundwater often differ from rules for streams.
- Some states treat groundwater under the same system as surface water, while others use separate rules such as reasonable use or correlative rights.
- Many states require permits or registration for wells above a certain size, and some limit pumping in designated basins or management areas.
- Groundwater and surface water are often connected, so heavy pumping can affect streams and neighbors' wells. Some states regulate conjunctive use.
- Local groundwater districts may add rules on spacing, pumping limits and metering.
The USGS water resources pages provide data on streamflow and groundwater that inform these decisions, though they do not determine legal rights.
Beneficial use and measurement
In appropriation states, a water right depends on putting water to a beneficial use, such as irrigation, stock watering or domestic use. Many states require measuring devices and annual reports, and some use telemetry. Keep your records of diversions, acres irrigated and dates, since they may be needed to prove use.
Before buying or leasing land
Do not assume water comes with land. Check:
- What rights exist. Obtain copies of permits, decrees and certificates from the state water agency.
- Priority date and quantity, which determines reliability in dry years.
- Place of use and point of diversion, which must match your use.
- Evidence of use, meaning historical records and aerial imagery showing irrigation, to detect forfeiture risk.
- Ditch or irrigation district memberships, assessments and shares, and delivery rules.
- Well permits, depth and capacity, and any basin restrictions.
- Liens, disputes or adjudication status. Some basins are still being adjudicated.
- Whether water is transferable, and what approvals a change would need.
A title company may not cover water rights, so a separate review is usually needed.
Changing use or efficiency
Changing the type, place or point of diversion of a right usually needs state approval, and others with rights can object if they would be harmed. Improving efficiency can have unintended legal effects: in some systems, if you reduce the amount you divert but the consumptive use stays the same, you keep your rights, while in others, conserved water may not be protected unless formally dedicated. Some states offer programs to leave saved water in the stream with legal protection, such as leasing or conservation transfers. Talk to your water agency and an attorney before changing diversion practices. See irrigation efficiency.
Ponds, dams and diversions
Even in states that allow farm ponds, there are often rules on size, dam safety, storage and impacts on downstream users. Stock ponds may be exempt from some requirements, and larger storage needs permits. Check with the state engineer or water agency, and with your conservation district. NRCS design standards apply to cost-shared structures. See rainwater harvesting.
Water quality rules are separate
Water rights say how much you may use. Water quality laws say what you may discharge. The Clean Water Act, state rules and local ordinances can apply to runoff, animal feeding operations and drainage. See the EPA agriculture portal and the EPA animal feeding operations page for federal requirements, and ask your state about additional rules.
Drought and shortages
In a shortage, priority matters. Junior users may be curtailed, wells may go dry, and states may impose emergency rules. Plan for the risk you hold: know where you sit in priority order and have contingency plans such as fallowing, alternative crops or leasing water. See drought-resistant crops. The U.S. Drought Portal offers monitoring and planning tools.
Leasing and markets
Many states allow temporary water leases or transfers, sometimes through water banks or markets. Prices fluctuate with supply. Leasing can bring income in dry years or help meet needs when the farm lacks senior rights, but transfer approvals and rules about third-party effects can be complex.
Where to get help
- State water resources or engineer's office for permits, records and rules.
- Irrigation or water districts for delivery rights and local rules.
- Extension for water management and legal primers. Many land-grant universities publish water law guides.
- A water attorney for transactions, disputes and planning.
- Conservation districts and NRCS for technical help. Find them in the state page of the directory.
Bottom line
Water rights determine whether a farm can use water, and how reliably. Learn which doctrine applies to your state, verify what rights actually come with land, keep records of beneficial use and seek legal help before changing or buying. Few mistakes are more expensive than assuming water without checking.
Frequently asked questions
What is prior appropriation?
A water law doctrine, common in the West, where the first to put water to beneficial use holds a senior right that is filled before junior rights in shortage.
What are riparian rights?
Rights of landowners next to a stream or lake to make reasonable use of the water, common in eastern states and often supplemented by permit systems.
Do I need a permit for a well?
Many states require permits or registration for wells, especially larger ones or those in managed basins. Check with your state water agency.
Can I lose a water right?
In many prior appropriation states, unused rights can be lost through forfeiture or abandonment, so document your use and get legal advice before leaving water unused.